NOVEMBER 3, 2021
To Maximize Solar Performance, Start Thinking Long Term
When solar asset managers open their proverbial pockets to contract with a long-term O&M company, the opportunity to maximize solar plant performance is often doomed from the start. With a limited supply chain of critical replacement parts, a shrinking labor pool causing labor cost increases, and the looming realization that the financial models may be based on overly aggressive modeling, it’s easy to fall back on short-term fixes.
It’s been reported that the PV industry is operating at a 6% average production shortfall, and this type of single-digit shortfall can have a dramatic 40% reduction in equity cash flows over a 10 year period. As outlined in a recent webinar with WoodMackenzie and kWh Analytics, many system owners have no choice but to narrow O&M scopes that are outsourced to third-party O&M service providers, opt to perform some elements internally, or forgo them all together with the hope that it will all work out in the end.
At Borrego, we believe that this dynamic needs to change and that responsible long-term O&M planning will help system owners gain back the most financial value from their solar assets. Here are some key considerations for thinking long-term about your solar plant performance.
Preventative vs. Corrective Maintenance
Asset owners know that Preventative Maintenance for solar projects is table-stakes for solar asset management: for long-term system health, corresponding asset value, and ensuring that critical warranties on expensive equipment are not voided. As the WoodMac webinar suggests, Preventative Maintenance alone isn’t enough to maximize long-term solar plant performance and obtain the most value from an asset.
Corrective Maintenance issues regularly arise, whether they impact availability or not. Today, Borrego O&M manages over 1,000 PV sites totaling 1.2 GWs across the United States. With these project sites under our care, we’ve successfully executed 2,100 corrective O&M services needed in 2021 so far. These reactive issues occurred in approximately 57% of our fleet. In other words, half of the project sites under our care required 4.2 “unplanned” services by the end of Q3-2021.
In our experience, when corrective maintenance is prioritized over preventative care, we see a 2% overall raw availability increase in site performance. (Note – this statement annualized monthly availability values and hasn’t been adjusted for utility outages or impacts of snow on arrays).
There is a wide range of corrective O&M issues that we commonly see working on over 1.2GW of large-scale solar power plants. The majority are system outages, utility and non-utility caused. Other common problems include failed termination, external damage, inverter failures with total replacement needed, and failed breakers, fuses, or other internal components. These commonly occurring issues are some of the most significant causes of lowered system production, and they typically fall outside the scope of most preventative maintenance packages.
Beyond Maintenance Related Issues
There are instances when an asset owner may need special O&M services, depending on the complexity and skills required to solve the cases that arise. These additional services can include performance engineering analysis, site investigations, upgrades, and complex replacements. Some of these issues occur at specific times during solar asset operation, such as inverter-related replacements and upgrades around years 15 and on. Other O&M problems can occur anytime during the asset life when needed, such as weather-related damage. In the diagram below, we illustrate the most common O&M issues and service needs across the asset lifetime.
Here is a brief rundown of the timing and typical scope of some of the most common O&M repair services needed for solar power plants:
- EPC phase and Year 1
- If you own your assets and self-perform O&M, your lenders may require or find it beneficial to have a third party provide a commissioning inspection.
- Within year one, solar asset owners may need repair work from the EPC build. We have seen failures from improper breaker torquing, loose bolts, and poor underground cable installation.
- Years 5-8 and beyond
- For solar roof installations, it’s not uncommon to see requests around year 5 to remove systems, replace the roof, and replace systems.
- Also, there is more demand for engineering performance analysis around year 5. For example, we performed an independent engineering analysis for SunRay that was ultimately used to meet their lender’s requirements. We looked at historical performance, forecasted future performance and compiled recommendations to improve performance.
- Later years – years 15 and beyond
- After year 15, one of the most common asset services is repowering which is often accompanied by system upgrades for modules and inverters. It is often beneficial for asset owners to replace their central inverters with string inverters when repowering.
- Besides repowering, other issues arise with aging systems such as foundation crumbling, electrical equipment deterioration, etc.
- As part of preventative maintenance services, necessary repairs or replacements may be identified that fall beyond the scope of standard preventative maintenance. During our preventative maintenance work, our skilled technicians often recognize issues and make recommendations for improvements to improve overall system health and performance.
- Additionally, performance anomalies or alerts routinely happen as part of proactive system monitoring, enabling an O&M provider to initiate and make corrective maintenance repairs.
- Weather-related damage can occur at any point in a system’s operation and are typically outside the maintenance scope. Examples of weather-related damage include water damage, including water intrusion and corrosion; misaligned and degrading equipment from erosion changes; broken and damaged panels from lightning, hail, and wind damage; and UV deterioration such as degraded & exposed wiring.
- With the increase in wildfires in recent years in the Western U.S., additional washing may be needed to get the desired asset performance.
Maximizing Performance of Solar Assets
These examples illustrate how a long-term mindset is needed to improve performance and system health issues and ultimately increase the value of your solar assets. Our team of technical subject matter experts is available to investigate, troubleshoot, repair, and upgrade large-scale solar systems. They draw from extensive field experience and technical analysis on the more than 1.2 GW we manage.
At Borrego, we provide a three-part approach to our O&M service offerings to support our customers with the three core areas facing their system’s performance across the entire solar asset lifetime. These include:
- Investigation & Performance Engineering Analysis
- Replacement & Upgrades
- Proactive Monitoring & Preventative Maintenance & Repair
Reach out to us if you need help planning and budgeting for system performance issues or correcting them. We can start by evaluating your portfolio’s performance and make recommendations for performance improvement.
Stay tuned for future blog posts where we will go into more detail on the causes of underperformance in solar portfolios and potential solutions.